There isn’t one hardest scale on guitar. How hard a scale feels depends on what you measure: finger stretches, unfamiliar interval patterns, or how hard the scale is to use musically. Pentatonic scales are often the easiest place to start. Altered, diminished and microtonal scales are the ones most often named as hard.
What makes a scale hard to play
Four things usually make a scale harder:
- Unusual interval patterns. A three-fret augmented second breaks the standard box shapes and needs extra mapping. Harmonic minor has one. Hungarian minor and the double harmonic scale each have two.
- Note count. Eight-note scales, such as the diminished scales, don’t divide evenly into three-notes-per-string patterns. But more notes doesn’t always mean harder. The chromatic scale has 12 notes and a simple repeating pattern.
- Stretches. Some modes need wide reaches or heavy pinky use, especially lower on the neck.
- Musical context. Scales with a lot of tension can be harder to resolve smoothly, and it can be harder to find practice material for them than for pentatonic or major scales.
Scales most often named as hard
These come up most often in discussions of difficulty:
- Altered scale (mode 7 of melodic minor): 1, b9, #9, 3, #11, b13, b7. It is hard mainly because it’s used over altered dominant chords in jazz, which can change quickly.
- Diminished scales. The whole-half version works over diminished seventh chords. The half-whole version works over dominant 7b9 chords. The half-whole pattern repeats every three frets.
- Whole-tone scale. Six notes, all whole steps. Its fingering repeats every two frets.
- Hungarian minor and double harmonic. Both have two augmented seconds. Hungarian minor is 1, 2, b3, #4, 5, b6, 7. Double harmonic is 1, b2, 3, 4, 5, b6, 7.
- Microtonal scales, such as Arabic maqam with quarter tones. They can’t be fretted on a standard guitar, so they need bends, slides or a different instrument.
A rough ladder, easier to harder
This ordering is our own judgment, not a consensus. Other players will rank these differently.
| Scale | Notes | Why it can be tricky |
|---|---|---|
| Minor pentatonic | 5 | Common benchmark: two notes per string |
| Major and natural minor | 7 | Standard three-notes-per-string patterns |
| Harmonic minor | 7 | One three-fret augmented second per position |
| Whole-tone | 6 | Repeats every two frets, with no strong home note |
| Melodic minor modes | 7 | Some modes, such as Lydian dominant, add unfamiliar tension |
| Diminished | 8 | Doesn’t divide evenly into three-note patterns |
| Altered | 7 | Fast chord changes in jazz make it hard to apply |
| Microtonal | Varies | Can’t be fretted on a standard guitar |
What to learn first
Start with the minor pentatonic, then the major and natural minor scales. Harmonic minor comes next, since the augmented second is the main new idea. Once the basic patterns feel comfortable, the less common scales are easier to place.
A harder scale doesn’t make better music. Much rock and blues uses pentatonic and major or minor scales. Good starting points are the minor pentatonic positions, the major scale patterns, and F harmonic minor.