Short answer: both work, so choose by tone and genre
Neither method is wrong. Choose by the sound you want and the music you play, and learn both if you can. Many bassists use one as their main approach and reach for the other when a song calls for it.
Tone
- Fingers give a rounder, warmer sound with a softer attack, and wide control over dynamics.
- A pick gives a brighter sound with a more defined attack and more midrange and treble. It cuts through distorted guitars.
- Where you pluck matters with either method. Near the neck sounds warmer and fuller. Near the bridge sounds brighter and tighter.
EQ can narrow the difference between the two, but it can’t remove the difference in attack.
Genres
- Fingers are common in funk, soul, jazz, R&B, reggae and most rock.
- A pick is common in punk, pop-punk, and some rock and metal.
These are tendencies, not rules.
Fingerstyle basics
- Alternate your index and middle fingers, using rest strokes.
- Some players add the ring finger, which is a three-finger technique.
- Silence unused strings with a floating thumb or a moveable anchor.
- Slap and pop use the thumb and fingers, so they aren’t possible with a pick in your hand.
Pick basics
- Bass picks are commonly around 0.88 to 1.5 mm. Thin picks can flap on heavy bass strings.
- Alternate picking helps with speed. All downstrokes suit driving punk eighth notes.
- To mute, palm-mute near the bridge and use your fretting hand to silence the unused strings.
Speed and consistency
A pick isn’t automatically faster. Skilled fingerstyle players can match pick speed. Picks aren’t only a fix for beginners with sore fingers.
Bassists who use each
Pick players include Mike Dirnt and, on many recordings, Paul McCartney. Fingerstyle players include James Jamerson, who played with one finger, and Jaco Pastorius.
Calluses and blisters
Calluses form over a few weeks of regular playing, and blisters are common early on. Let blisters heal before heavy playing, and keep sessions moderate while your fingers adjust.
Most method books teach fingerstyle first, though this varies. Learning both is worthwhile.
How to decide
- Try both on the same bass. Play the same short passage with each method, record it and listen back.
- Start with the genre you play most. Funk and soul lean toward fingers, and punk leans toward a pick.
- Keep a pick in your case. It’s handy when a song calls for one.
For the first steps on the instrument, see how to start playing bass guitar. For a long-term practice plan, see how to make faster progress on bass.